Wednesday, January 19, 2005

One way to win a DUI dismissal is..

... to be an elected official!

How DUI case was dropped By Rob Olmstead Daily Herald Staff WriterPosted Wednesday, January 19, 2005
DuPage County State's Attorney Joseph Birkett is tough on drunken drivers. On that, prosecutors, defense attorneys and advocates against drunken driving all agree.
But when Cook County gang crimes prosecutor Joseph E. Keating, 43, was arrested in July and charged with DUI after knocking over a light pole on an I-55 ramp, he managed to get the charge dropped at his first court appearance.
The reason, prosecutors said, was not that Keating was a prosecutor himself, but that the case was weak. That's because Keating refused all sobriety tests, including a Breathalyzer, and police failed to activate the audio portion of the videotape of the arrest.
Keating won't talk about the arrest. Birkett says the case was not winnable without Breathalyzer results or conclusive evidence from the scene.
Keating notified his bosses in Cook County of the arrest and was put on desk duty while his case was pending, according to Marci Jensen, a spokeswoman for Cook County State's Attorney Richard Devine. He was reinstated to the courtroom when the DUI charge was dropped Aug. 13, she said.
Asked if the fact that a prosecutor refused drunken driving tests bothered the office, Jensen replied that Keating was entitled to the same options as any other driver.
Court records indicate Keating pleaded guilty to failing to reduce speed to avoid an accident and paid about $360 in fees and fines. Keating also paid to replace the light pole. Court records said it the first accusation of DUI against Keating. He did not receive a summary suspension called for under Illinois law for refusing to take the Breathalyzer test.
Keating was placed on court supervision for the charge he pleaded guilty to, meaning that if he makes it to his final court date in February without other traffic problems, the case will not go on his record with the secretary of state.
Birkett acknowledged that dropped DUI charges, while rare in DuPage are not unheard of -- "probably between 6 and 10 percent," he said.
The DuPage County prosecutor's office handles thousands of DUI cases a year. A Daily Herald review of 20 of them brought in DuPage County at the same time as the Keating case found that Keating's DUI charge was the only one the office dropped.
Birkett has made a reputation for himself and earned the admiration of advocates against drunken driving for being tough with DUIs, sometimes even prosecuting cases with weak evidence, defense attorneys say.
At least one veteran defense attorney, whose office handles about 50 DUIs a year, says he's never seen the DuPage office drop a DUI case. Even if a case is weak, Des Plaines attorney Michael R. Epton said he's seen DuPage prosecutors leave it to a judge to throw it out.
By office policy, front-line prosecutors cannot, of their own volition, drop or reduce a DUI charge, Birkett said. They must seek approval from a supervisor first. The same policy operates in Cook County, Jensen said.
Birkett said the Keating case never reached his desk, but it did go up the chain of command through at least three supervisors. He said he supports their decision.
Keating's crash
In Keating's case, state police were called to the northbound I-55 ramp from northbound Lemont Road around 8:45 p.m. on July 16. Keating's green 1998 Oldsmobile had left the roadway, striking a light pole and knocking it over, blocking all ramp traffic.
A Darien police officer was already on the scene when rookie trooper Noel Tarr -- on his first DUI stop -- and his trainer, veteran trooper Darren Love, arrived at 9:04 p.m.
On their video, Keating is seen walking out of the ditch and then taking a call on his cell phone. At 9:05, Love talks to Keating and a minute later, Keating hands his cell phone to an unidentified woman. More people walk into the scene, sometimes blocking the view of Keating, and at 9:08, officers cuff Keating and lead him to the squad car at 9:10.
Nowhere on the tape does Keating stumble or stagger, a fact that Jeff Kendall, deputy chief of the felony division and one of the supervisors who OK'd the dropped charge, cited as a reason. As did Birkett.
"The officer's report was impeached by the video," he said.
The troopers' court filing said Keating had "glassy, bloodshot eyes, slurred speech and an odor of alcohol." But there was no audio portion to the video by which to gauge Keating's speech.
Illinois State Police and Kendall refused to release their police report but read portions of it to the Daily Herald. In it, police say they asked Keating to stand by the squad door. There, out of the camera's view, he stumbled one step to his left, the officers claimed.
The officers also noted that Keating's car left the roadway along a straight portion of the ramp, and when they asked him about alcohol, he admitted he had been drinking earlier in the day at a golf outing.
At the station, the report said, police again asked Keating to take a Breathalyzer, warning him his license could be automatically suspended for six months for refusing. He again refused.
Keating, reached by phone at his office at the Cook County Criminal Courts at 26th and California in Chicago, wasn't talking.
"I don't have a comment," he said.
The court case
Besides dropping the DUI charge, DuPage prosecutors did not pursue summary suspension of Keating's driver's license, either. Under Illinois law, drivers who refuse sobriety tests are supposed to lose their license for six months on a first offense, whereas a first-time DUI conviction nets just three months suspension.
However, dropping the summary suspension is not unusual. In many of the cases the Daily Herald examined, once a DUI plea was reached, the summary suspension was dropped.
In the 20 cases surveyed by the Daily Herald, seven were still pending, two were thrown out by judges, nine guilty pleas were obtained and two were bargained down from DUI.
Of those two, one was Keating's case. The other was a case prosecuted by a municipality, not DuPage County.
And in one of the two cases thrown out by a judge, prosecutors still had pressed the case even though police officers failed to respond to a defense subpoena, diminishing the evidence against the defendants.
Defense attorney Epton said those circumstances sound familiar.
"I haven't been successful with getting them to plea bargain at all," said Epton when asked how often he's seen DuPage prosecutors plea bargain a DUI charge or drop it outright. "I haven't seen the state amend a case yet."
Another defense attorney and former prosecutor, Chuck Rohde, of Addison, agreed that in his experience cases that would be dropped routinely in other jurisdictions are regularly prosecuted in DuPage County.
For example, he said, he recently defended a case in Cook County at the Rolling Meadows courthouse in which the complaining police officer showed up to testify but the defendant refused sobriety tests. The Cook prosecutor dropped the case before it went to trial.
"I think the odds of that happening in DuPage County are one in a million," Rohde said.
Instead, DuPage prosecutors normally make the defendant go to trial and at least rack up attorney's fees, he said.
"At the end of the day, you'd get the same result, but you would have to go through the trial," Rohde said.
Not all defense attorneys find it so odd for DuPage to drop such a case, though. George Kallas, of Wheaton, -- himself a former prosecutor -- said he's seen DuPage prosecutors drop cases under certain circumstances.
"Could be the guy passes all the field sobriety tests or he blows under the legal limit," Kallas said.
Charlene Chapman of Alliance Against Intoxicated Motorists said her organization has been impressed with Birkett's doggedness at pursuing DUI cases. She praised him as a man of integrity and said AAIM had yet to discover a case dropped under suspicious circumstances in DuPage.
Tarr, one of the troopers involved in the arrest, declined to speculate on how the case was prosecuted. He is no longer a trooper and he declined to explain why. Love, the other trooper, could not be reached for comment despite repeated attempts.
Kendall said it would have been irresponsible to proceed on the Keating case.
"We have a responsibility to justice, and we can't go forward on a case if we can't reasonably expect to succeed," he said.
When asked for examples of other dropped cases, Kendall recalled a DuPage police officer who prosecutors discovered was putting false statements in his reports.
"We probably had to dismiss tens if not 100 (DUI) cases," Kendall said.
The officer, whom Kendall declined to identify by name or department, was eventually fired, Kendall said.
Birkett is adamant that the Keating case was prosecuted like any other.
"My policy is you treat elected or appointed officials the same as anyone else," Birkett said.
As for Cook County's assertion that Keating's standing as a prosecutor required no more of him than would be expected of any other citizen, AAIM's Chapman disagreed.
"I think they should be held to a higher standard," she said, "because they're the ones prosecuting other drunk drivers."
• In short: The DuPage County prosecutor's office is as tough as they get on drunken drivers. But when an assistant Cook County state's attorney was arrested in DuPage on suspected DUI after he knocked over a light pole, he refused sobriety tests and got his case dropped at his first hearing.
DUI: Prosecutor says pursuit of case would be irresponsible

22 Comments:

Blogger Squirrel said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

12:52 AM

 
Anonymous california dui said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

2:27 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Latest news. Viagra, cialis

viagra
cialis
tramadol

5:22 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

could the woman be another prosecutor that keating has worked with for many years? could he have been consumming alchohol with her after the golf outing that he admitting drink at earlier that day? could she have been following keating because of his obviously intoxicated state? but why not just take his keys,offer to drive him.poor judgement for two people who consider themselves to be good judges of character enough to run for judges at election time!previously unidentified female a.s.a catherine sanders has in fact persued judgeship on a number of occasions. one might assume that perhaps there was something as equally inappropriate as drunk driving going on that clouded their "judgement" besides liquor.maybe the thought of keatings wife and three kids at home and what an uncomfortable situation that would create didn't leave much room for level headed tinking

10:36 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Jealous?

5:46 PM

 
Blogger camilyn said...

Driving under the influence of alcohol is regarded to be one with the severe crimes around the world. Most of the countries have severe punishment for this type of criminal offence, as whenever drunk and driving it might end up in incidents that injures other individuals too. In case when one is booked for drunken drive, the very best, the individual can do would be to hire DUI Lawyers to save him.

2:19 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Article writing is also a fun, if you know afterward you can write or else it
is complicated to write.

Have a look at my site compositor

3:04 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice at the same
time as you amend your website, how could i subscribe for a weblog site?
The account aided me a acceptable deal. I have been tiny bit acquainted
of this your broadcast provided vivid clear concept

Feel free to visit my website jocuri online multiplayer browser

9:39 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello colleagues, how is everything, and what you would like to say on the topic of this post, in my view its really remarkable designed for me.


My homepage radio erevan bancuri

10:02 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am actually thankful to the holder of this web site who has shared this impressive post at at this place.



Also visit my homepage :: jocuri online download

12:31 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very great post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted to
mention that I've really loved surfing around your weblog posts. In any case I'll be subscribing on
your feed and I am hoping you write again very soon!


my homepage; bancuri politehnica

1:24 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Does your blog have a contact page? I'm having a tough time locating it but, I'd like to
shoot you an email. I've got some ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it develop over time.

Feel free to surf to my site :: bancuri cu informaticieni

2:25 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

As the admin of this web page is working, no hesitation very
quickly it will be famous, due to its quality contents.


My page ... jocuri jocuri online

10:39 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Every weekend i used to visit this website, as i wish
for enjoyment, for the reason that this this site conations truly pleasant funny data too.


Review my blog post - anuncios clasificados gratis

4:13 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Joe Keating is a good man and an excellent prosecutor and a dedicated public servant.

1:03 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The lady that was mentioned above as the unidentified female who was the ASA. I am glad that she was neither appointed nor elected to the bench. Her failure to win the election does to a certain degree restore somewhat my confidence in the intelligence and fairness of the American people at election time. That is the beauty of democracy. Fairness and humility is something that all of us myself first should strive to attain and maintain. I hope this lady can do the same.

1:09 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cathy Sanders humility? Do not count on it.

9:36 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cathy Sanders does not know the meaning of the word humility. She would not have dismissed the charges if a similar case came to her desk for review. She and her female subordinates that she supervised also have this power hungry attitude and let's inflict pain on people. Did she learn humility from this experience? If she did the Brooklyn Bridge is for sale. Thankfully she did not become a judge.

10:30 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Catherine Sanders is a vindictive piece of shit.

8:27 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cathy Sanders is a vindictive person who will go out of her way to hurt people. Thankfully she is not wearing a black robe where her vindictiveness and ego would reach astronomical levels. The site of her wearing a black robe would make me want to throw up. Yuck

2:01 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

very true

10:26 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Assistant States Attorney Cathy or Catherine Sanders still vindictive. Still ugly. Still a miserable nasty person who knows no limits to her vindictiveness I think it is an abomination that she is a Trustee at Lemont Public Library. Makes me want to puke Very sickening Thankfully she is not on the bench. Great job Cook County voters in keeping her off the bench. Nasty woman just nasty

11:31 AM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home